Most Psychotherapy Starts in the Wrong Place
CBT starts with thoughts and behaviour
Trauma therapy starts with trauma
Attachment work starts with attachment
Psychodynamic therapy starts with unconscious processes
Somatic work starts with the body
Addiction treatment may start with disease, powerlessness, coping, regulation or relapse prevention
But there is an even earlier starting point we rarely examine
Teacher / student
Expert / patient
Knower / sufferer
Healer / wounded
Interpreter / interpreted
Helper / person who needs help
Most therapists would reject those descriptions!
Yet the beliefs can remain hidden in the process even when the language changes
We say collaborative, but the therapist still decides what counts as progress
We say client-led, but the therapist still holds the formulation
We say the client has the answers, while deciding which answers show insight and which show avoidance, resistance or denial
Then the model begins organising the person before the person has had a chance to show us who they are
Once I believe I know what matters, my questions change
I notice what fits
I interpret what I hear through the theory
Then I call the result formulation
And something even more subtle can happen
The therapist offers an explanation
The client feels seen
The client agrees
The therapist experiences that agreement as confirmation
The client experiences the therapist’s confidence as proof they are finally understanding themselves
A shared story forms
That’s my trauma
That’s my attachment
That’s my nervous system
That’s my schema
It can feel like progress….
But relief is not necessarily transformation
Coherence is not necessarily truth
And becoming better at explaining yourself is not necessarily becoming free
Therapist and client can unknowingly collaborate in an explanation that makes both feel therapy is working, and often the only person getting value is therapist being validated, the client is buying the illusion of progress
What if the person’s experience does not organise itself according to the model?
What if their fear is not trauma?
What if their substance use is not avoidance?
What if their anger is not dysregulation?
What if what looks like resistance is intelligence?
A model can describe
It can orient
It can offer language
But it cannot know the person in front of me
psychotherapy should not begin with
Which model best explains this person?
it should begin with:
I don’t know yet. Show me
Then, if a model helps later, use it
But let the person come first
Because therapy can help while still misunderstanding why it helped