Lived Experience can Make you Worse at Helping People
It did for me
For years, I thought my lived experience gave me an advantage
I had been addicted
I had got clean
I had decades of recovery behind me
Then came the credentials, the training, the clinical experience
And all of it seemed to confirm the same thing…
I knew what people with addiction needed
That was the problem
The more certain I became, the less curious I was
I recognised myself in people and assumed I understood them
I used my clean time as evidence
I imposed 12 Step ideas because they had helped me stop
And sometimes people did stop using
From the outside, that looked like success
But looking back, many of them did not become free
They became more like I was
No drugs
No alcohol
But still organised around fear, control, avoidance, compulsive behaviour, food, relationships, work, sex, approval, whatever else could change the state
We had changed the behaviour
We had not necessarily changed the need
And the uncomfortable truth is that my lived experience often got in the way
So did my training
So did my credentials
Not because any of them were useless
Because I mistook them for evidence that I already understood the person in front of me
The thing I actually needed was much simpler and much harder
To stop knowing
To listen
To stay curious
To let another person’s experience be different from mine
Lived experience can create connection
It can reduce shame
It can build trust
But the moment it becomes
I’ve been where you are, so I know what you need
it becomes a barrier
My addiction taught me about my addiction
It did not make me an expert on yours!!
And perhaps the greatest value of lived experience is not that it gives us answers
It is that, if we have really learned from it, it should leave us humble enough to ask better questions