WHEN SOMEONE TELLS YOU WHAT’S WRONG WITH YOU
Have you ever tried to explain how you feel to someone who seems convinced they know you better than you know yourself?
You tell them you’re upset
They tell you you’re overreacting
You try to explain why something hurt you
They tell you it’s because of your childhood
You disagree
They tell you you’re being defensive
And the more you try to explain yourself, the more convinced they become that they’re right
Eventually, you give up trying
I’ve seen this happen in relationships, families, addiction recovery and therapy
Sometimes the person doing it genuinely believes they’re helping
They’ve studied psychology. They’ve learned about trauma, attachment and human behaviour
They recognise something in you that fits what they’ve learned
And now they believe they understand you
Your anger is a defence mechanism
Your silence is avoidance
Your disagreement is resistance
Your sadness is unresolved trauma
Everything you say becomes evidence for an explanation they’ve already decided is true
Imagine what it’s like to be on the receiving end of that
You came hoping to be understood
Now you’re trying to convince them that their understanding of you is wrong
And somehow, even that becomes part of your problem
After decades working with people experiencing addiction and mental health difficulties, this concerns me
We have developed countless ways to explain human suffering
Some explanations can be genuinely helpful
But there’s a danger when we become so attached to an explanation that we stop listening
A person might be angry because they’re frightened
They might be angry because they’ve been treated unfairly
They might be angry because someone keeps telling them what’s wrong with them
How would we know if we’ve already decided what their anger means?
I’ve met people who have spent years believing things about themselves because someone in authority told them those things were true
That they were powerless
That they were damaged
That their thinking couldn’t be trusted
That their disagreement was evidence of their problem
Some carried those beliefs for decades
I’ve also had to question many explanations I once accepted about myself
That’s why we need to be careful about the authority we give our interpretations of another human being
Especially when someone is vulnerable and looking to us for help
There’s a real difference between someone discovering something about themselves and being persuaded to accept what we believe about them
We can be completely convinced that we understand another person and still be wrong
And if we can’t allow someone to disagree with our interpretation without turning their disagreement into another symptom, how can that person ever be heard?
I wonder how many people have spent years trying to fix something about themselves that somebody else convinced them was wrong in the first place