YOU DISAGREE? THAT’S YOUR DISEASE TALKING
Imagine being told that questioning something is proof that there’s something wrong with you
You disagree with your sponsor? You’re in denial
You question whether you’re powerless? That’s your ego talking
You think you might be able to recover another way? That’s your disease trying to kill you
You want to leave the programme? You’ll probably relapse
Sound familiar?
I spent 2 decades+ in 12-step recovery, and I heard variations of these statements countless times
For a long time, I believed them
And there’s something deeply troubling about what happens when we start interpreting disagreement as evidence of illness
How can you ever question a belief if questioning it is taken as proof that the belief is true?
Think about that.
If you agree with the programme, you’re making progress
If you disagree, you’re in denial
If you stay, you’re doing the right thing
If you leave and relapse, it proves you needed the programme
If you leave and remain well, somehow your experience doesn’t count
At what point does a belief become impossible to challenge?
And what happens to the person caught inside it?
Imagine arriving somewhere frightened, desperate, perhaps already convinced there’s something fundamentally wrong with you
You meet people who appear to have found an answer
You trust them
You begin to understand yourself through what they teach you
And eventually, even your own doubts become something you’re taught to distrust
I wonder how many people have stopped asking questions because they’ve learned to interpret their own curiosity as a warning sign
I know I did
And here’s something I find interesting
The Alcoholics Anonymous Big Book actually says:
“Our book is meant to be suggestive only”
“We realize we know only a little”
Yet I’ve encountered people who speak as though questioning those suggestions is dangerous
How did we get from acknowledging that we know only a little to behaving as though we know exactly what’s happening inside another human being?
I’ve met people whose lives have been transformed by AA. I know how valuable those rooms are
I’ve also met people who spent years believing they were failing because they couldn’t make this approach work for them
And I’ve met people who found freedom when they finally began questioning what they’d been told about themselves
I was one of them
After 22 years, I left
I’m still clean
And I’m still asking questions
When did disagreement become a symptom?
When did curiosity become denial?
And when did another human being’s understanding of themselves become less important than our interpretation of them?
One of the most important things we can offer someone who’s struggling is the freedom to question what we believe
Including the things that helped us
Because if our understanding is genuinely helpful, surely it can withstand a question
And if it can’t, perhaps we have something to learn